The Dutch data protection authority imposed the fine on the Dutch Tax and Customs Authority (Belastingdienst) for several data protection breaches in connection with an unlawfully maintained list on which the tax authority recorded indications of fraud (Fraude Signalering Voorziening, FSV).
The list had existed for a period of more than six years and contained entries on approximately 270,000 persons. For those who were wrongly on the list, i.e. were listed as possible fraudsters without reason, the listing often had serious consequences. As the investigation revealed, the Belastingdienst staff had sometimes assessed the risk of fraud on the basis of the nationality and appearance of the persons concerned.
Most importantly, the authority found that the Belastingdienst had no legal basis for the processing of personal data associated with such a list. Consequently, the data of the data subjects had been processed unlawfully for years.
Furthermore, the recipient of the fine had violated several principles of data processing (lawfulness and transparency, purpose limitation, accuracy, storage limitation). For example, the data stored on the list were often incorrect or not up-to-date and had been kept for too long. In addition, the Belastingdienst had not precisely defined the processing purposes of the list in advance.
The data protection authority also identified failures on the part of the tax authority with regard to the security of the processing. In this context, the authority criticised the fact that the recipient of the fine had not involved its internal data protection officer in the data protection impact assessment in good time. The data protection officer was not consulted until one year after the data protection impact assessment had been carried out.
The sanction is the highest fine ever imposed by the Dutch data protection authority. The amount of the fine is made up proportionately of: EUR 1,000,000 for a breach of Art. 5(1)(a) and Art. 6(1) GDPR, EUR 750,000 for a breach of Art. 5(1)(b) GDPR, EUR 750,000 for a breach of Art. 5(1)(d) GDPR, EUR 250,000 for a breach of Art. 5(1)(e) GDPR, EUR 500,000 for a breach of Art. 32(1) GDPR and EUR 450,000 for a breach of Art. 35(2) GDPR.