| fineID | Date | Fine | Recipient | Country | Infringement | href | Land |
|---|
Deliveroo Italy s.r.l. is an Italian food delivery service which is a subsidiary of the Irish company Roofoods LTD. The penalty notice relates to a series of inspections on the handling of employee data carried out by the Italian data protection authority at some of the largest food delivery companies operating in Italy. The round of inspections, of which the present notice is a part, focused specifically on drivers as data subjects. The data protection authority found serious violations of applicable data protection regulations on the part of Deliveroo Italy. A total of 8,000 drivers are affected.
Deliveroo had used a centralised system for driver management, which was administered by Roofoods in Ireland. After signing the contract, drivers were given an access code for the Deliveroo driver app, which they had to install on their smartphones and link to their phone number and email address. The app was then used to process and manage the contracting and booking of shifts.
Some grievances concerned the algorithms that the delivery service had used for this. For example, the company had not sufficiently informed workers about how the system worked and had not guaranteed the accuracy and correctness of the results of the algorithmic systems used to evaluate drivers. In this context, the authority stressed that it was the company's responsibility to check the correctness of the results of the algorithms at regular intervals in order to minimise the risk of biased or discriminatory effects. Nor were procedures established to protect the right to human intervention, expression of opinion and challenge of decisions made on the basis of the algorithms used by Deliveroo Italy.
With regard to the data processing carried out by the systems, the DPA also found violations of the principles of data minimisation as well as storage limitation. Firstly, the systems processed driver data in a way that was more extensive than necessary for the purpose of the processing. For example, drivers' location data had been collected every 12 seconds and stored with a large amount of personal data collected during the execution of orders (including communication with customer service). Secondly, the storage period of the different types of data had not been defined in a manner appropriate to the purpose. Instead, the company had only defined a flat retention period of six years.
Furthermore, the company had not implemented adequate technical and organisational measures to ensure a level of protection appropriate to the risk for the data subjects. Deliveroo Italy had also not conducted a data protection impact assessment, although this would have been necessary due to the risk posed to the drivers. In this context, the data protection authority also recognised a failure on the part of the delivery service to implement data protection through technology design and through data protection-friendly default settings.
Furthermore, the company's register of its processing activities did not comply with the requirements of data protection law. It did not describe in detail the technical and organisational security measures implemented by the delivery service, but only referred to an unspecified security concept.
Similarly, the data controller had provided the contact details of its data protection officer to the data protection authority late, namely only on 31 May 2019. During the investigation, Deliveroo Italy justified this by stating that its data protection officer was the same as the one of its corporate group and that the parent company had already made a corresponding notification in May 2018. This notwithstanding, the authority found that Deliveroo Italy, as the data controller, was obliged to make an independent notification.