| fineID | Date | Fine | Recipient | Country | Infringement | href | Land |
|---|
Between 8 June 2018 and 6 April 2019, the French data protection supervisory authority CNIL received 15 complaints from individuals about CARREFOUR Group companies. The complaints included advertising despite the objection of the data subjects, as well as exceeding the deadlines for requests for information and requests for erasure from data subjects.
The regulator then conducted audits at CARREFOUR FRANCE between 28 May and 27 June 2019, covering the Carrefour loyalty programme, customer databases and technical and organisational measures.
During the investigations, the CNIL found that the customer database for marketing campaigns stored records of customers whose last contact or transaction was up to four years ago. However, the authority considered a maximum of three years to be appropriate. Furthermore, other databases still stored data on more than 28 million loyalty programme participants who had been inactive for up to 10 years.
When investigating the fulfilment of data subjects' rights, the CNIL found that copies of personal identity cards were kept for up to six years as proof of identity for data subjects' requests. According to the authority, the copies should have been deleted immediately after the identity had been verified. Furthermore, the practice of requiring a copy of the identity card for any request from the person concerned was criticised. From the authority's point of view, this form of proof should have been limited to cases where there was doubt about the identity of the person concerned. It was also criticised that the processing times for data subject requests were up to nine months.
The authority also found the website carrefour.fr to be in breach of the GDPR due to a lack of accessibility to information under Articles 12 and 13 of the GDPR. The data protection notices were housed in multi-page terms of use, so that they were not easily accessible to data subjects. In addition, the information was distributed in several places on the website. Also, the postal advertising mailings of the loyalty programme on the data protection notices only listed a general reference to the website, but not the exact web address or name of the subpage. Furthermore, the authority criticised that the data protection notices contained unclear, ambiguous or imprecise formulations. Processing operations were generalised and presented by way of example, so that the transparency required by Articles 12 and 13 of the GDPR was not provided. The formulations were so complicated that the content was difficult to understand even for experts. With regard to the content of the data protection declarations, the authority criticised the fact that the person responsible for the carrefour.fr website could not be correctly identified, the legal basis and storage period of the processing was not stated and information on transfers to third countries was missing.
The supervisory authority also found a lack of technical and organisational measures. On the carrefour.fr website, customers' invoices could be accessed by anyone without any authentication. Only knowledge of the specific web address was enough to view the data.
On 1 July 2019, there was a password attack on the website's user accounts. With over 800,000 connection attempts from a bot net of 10,000 IP addresses, there were 4,000 successful authentications. As a result, there were unauthorised accesses to 275 user accounts. However, the incident was not reported to the CNIL.
The authority also criticised the fact that 39 cookies were set when the website was visited, most of which were not technically necessary. Among the cookies were three for tracking using Google Analytics. For the tracking cookies, visitors' consent would have been required.
The company did not agree with the publication of the report on the fine proceedings. However, the authority was convinced that the high number of affected persons would only learn about the violations of their rights through the publication.