| fineID | Date | Fine | Recipient | Country | Infringement | href | Land |
|---|
The Spanish regulator AEPD received five complaints about Banco Bilbao Vizcay Argentaria (BBVA) in 2018-2019. These included complaints about unsolicited advertising via SMS and telephone, as well as inadequate data protection notices.
During the course of the investigation, the AEPD thoroughly reviewed BBVA's privacy notices. Numerous deficiencies were found in the fulfilment of the information obligations as well as the lawfulness of the processing operations.
The data protection notices were criticised for their imprecise form and language that was not clear or simple. BBVA only used general formulations and thus violated the principle of transparency. The actual meaning and scope of the processing, especially those based on consent and legitimate interest, is not clear to the data subjects. Formulations such as "to improve the quality of products and services" or "to get to know you better" were used. The wording in the privacy statement is partly reflected as negative examples in the Guidance on Transparency under Regulation 2016/679 of the Article 29 Working Party.
In addition, the AEPD notes that the privacy notices do not make transparent and clearly understandable the purpose and legal basis, in particular for processing operations based on legitimate interest. Here, it was listed by way of example that the data protection notice does not sufficiently inform about the purposes of use of creditworthiness data that are collected via the query of credit agencies. This is lawful for the administration of the contractually agreed products and services, but not for the creation of customer profiles for marketing purposes.
It was also noted that the categories of personal data were not specified. It is not clear to the data subject which of his or her data is used for which of the many processing purposes. BBVA only amended its privacy policy in June 2020.
Furthermore, it was criticised that the requirements for specific, unambiguous and informed consent were not met. For some of the processing operations, opt-out was offered via documents that were not related to the non-specific purposes at all. One such document is the "Statement of Economic Activity and Company Policy", which is required to be signed by data subjects in many business transactions.
The AEPD also found that the justification for legitimate interest of processing operations is insufficient. Customers do not reasonably expect that their data will be used to improve products and services and enhance the customer experience. It is also noted that the necessity criterion as part of the proportionality test is not met for the purposes mentioned. Without a clear identification of the purposes of the processing, it is difficult to put forward legitimate interests that outweigh the interests or fundamental rights and freedoms of the data subject. The vagueness of the data used and the purposes do not allow for a statement on proportionality. Also, data collected due to legal requirements to prevent money laundering were processed for other purposes.
The AEPD is imposing a fine of 2 million euros for the violations of Art. 13 and 14 of the GDPR. For the violations of Art. 6 DSGVO, the fine amounts to 3 million euros. The fact that 8.3 million BBVA customers are affected by the violations was an aggravating factor in the calculation of the fine.